[Message Prev][Message Next][Thread Prev][Thread Next][Message Index][Thread Index]

[vsnet-chart-problem 36] R Aql: possible chart problem information




Object: R Aql
Chart : AAVSO
Source: vsnet-chart 439 (Sebastian Otero)
Comment: 

I have prepared a new chart for one of the most interesting changing period
miras, that incredible was observed by a lot of people with the most
terrible AAVSO chart that ever existed.
The b chart for R Aquilae showed up to 1.2 mag. differences between its
values and the V magnitudes from the ground or Tycho-2.
This is a comparison between the old chart values for stars now included in
my new one:

AAVSO       V    B-V

66           6.29   1.6
67           6.71   0.4
71           7.20   0.3
74           7.44   0.4
76           7.49   0.9
78           8.44   1.3
79           8.53   0.4
83           8.84   0.1
85sw       8.93   2.0
85w        9.65   0.7
88           9.29   2.0
89           9.32   0.5
91           9.36   1.4
95ssw     9.73   1.1
95s         9.53   0.6
101       10.35   0.7
111w    11.28   0.3
111nw  11.31   1.0
115nw  11.57   0.5

Unbelievable. Between the 76 and 78 comparison stars there is almost a full
magnitude difference and not just 0.2. One of the "85"s is actually 9.65
!!!!
I can imagine a false standstill when the star is between 7.6 and 7.8....
And if someone goes on to determine the limitting magnitude of his/her
binoculars, stars that are supposedly easy to find, won't even be observed
at all !!
Errors are not systematically bound to colors or a zero-point problem. They
are random so the resulting lightcurve is not truly representative of this
very important mira.

The charts (binocular and telescopic) are at:
http://ar.geocities.com/varsao/Carta_R_Aql.htm
http://ar.geocities.com/varsao/Carta_R_Aql_tel.htm

  ...


Return to Home Page

Return to the Powerful Daisaku Nogami

vsnet-adm@kusastro.kyoto-u.ac.jp

Powered by ooruri technology