vsnet administrator team received the following message from G. Sostero which was originally posted to vsnet-alert. The image attached to the mail will be sent later. Regards, Makoto Uemura ---------- Date: Fri, 03 Nov 2000 17:23:34 +0000 From: afamstar <afamstar@libero.it> Subject: [vsnet-alert 0] RE: Image of DSS zone M31 of suspected Nova Questo ,Ah(B un messaggio a pi,Ay(B sezioni in formato MIME. --------------DEDD2A0C7169B5CDF3CEE14B Content-Type: text/plain; charset=us-ascii Content-Transfer-Encoding: 7bit Hi all, with reference to the e-mail of mr.Scarmato, I would like to made a few comments: 1) the image we made on November 1st, was extremely deep (limiting magnitude almost 19.2), and the constrast/brightness parameters of it were very exaggereted, in order to extract the faint image of the possible (fading) Nova. The other two small dots visible in our frame, nearby the possible Nova could be, in my opinion: i) or extremely reddened foreground stars with a high R-I color index, in such a way that we catched it at the threshold limit of our frame, but they were not well recorded in the POSS plate ii) or noise of our CCD (very likely, this would be the correct answer). The problem is that when you try to catch extremely fainth objects, at the threshold limit of the frame, you are cleary fighting with the noise of your camera. Anyway the possible Nova is a real object, and is well visible not only on our frames, but also on that's of F. Ewalt, and in the following images of K. Korlevic. Is it a real Nova in M31? In my opinion, giving its photometric behaviour, we have only two possible answers: i) or a genuine Nova in M31 ii) or a Galactic cataclismic variable in the line of sight of M31 I would prefer the first option, because of the lightcurve, and also because I consider rather difficult that a cataclismic variable with peaking magnitude close to 17, was missed in all the previous extended professional surveys of M31 (Palomar, Asiago, etc.). Anyway only a spectra would give a clear answer, but unfortunately we haven't it... 2) the faint starlike point indicated with a small arrow in the POSS-R pictur by mr.Scarmato, is clearly a stellar source with a small B-R color index. You can recognize it looking at the enclosed POSS-B plate, where it is much evident. I consider that we cannot see it in our frames (as in the frames of F. Ewalt, K. Korlevic and that's of every observer using a CCD, that has the maximum sensitivity in the R-I band) just because of a color effect. Thanks to mr.Scarmato for the useful discussion he prompted. Best regards, Giovanni Sostero