Dear Dr Kato Thanks for querying this anomalous observation of AX Per. I have not observed this field very much and it looks like I did not identify properly. Please remove this observation from the lists: PERAX 990111.878 <13.6 HZM I see I also reported negatives for this star on 2nd and 5th January, so please also remove the following: PERAX 990102.886 <12.3 HZM PERAX 990105.906 <12.3 HZM Apologies to all. Best wishes Hazel McGee